Showing posts with label B-School and MBA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label B-School and MBA. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 6, 2007

5 things B-schools don’t teach!

Stepping out of B-school into the real world is like learning golf from manuals, or like teaching yourself cricket online. You have all the required theoretical inputs; a clear understanding of the rule book, the jargon and concepts; a dash of history to boot; and anecdotes and trivia as fillers.As this package comes in contact with reality, it goes through a range of emotions, starting with denial, wrath, angst, confusion, wonder, and finally settles into pragmatism, with bouts of nostalgia and a few clear learnings that are far removed from what the rule books preached.
The moral of the story: the real world teaches you some home truths that academia does not touch upon. In our journey down the road of experience, some of them get etched as gospels. If I were to pick a few of them, and share them here, they would be:
1. Brevity:
All the case studies, presentations, analysis and concept notes do not prepare you for the first reality of life. The world does not give you the opportunity to expound on theories over a 40-page Word document, or a 120-slide PowerPoint presentation.
In most real life situations, you get a tiny window in which you need to make your point, in as impactful a manner as possible. The more august the audience, the shorter the time.
From 10-second one-line summaries, to elevator pitches, to one paragraph e-mail, you need to cultivate the habit of being concise. There are no second opportunities in a real-time scenario.
Keeping that in mind, all your thinking needs to be crystallised and constantly carried around, to capitalise on the opportunity.
The clearer the thinking, the easier it is to say it succinctly. I would like to see the day when we put tight leashes around time, space and resources, and start recognising and appreciating brevity as a virtue in academics, instead of letting duration, length or aesthetics drive judgement.

2. People skills:
Real life is about real people. It involves dealing with diverse personalities, cultural backgrounds and competencies that you do not normally encounter in B-school. The challenge is, thus, compounded and you often see stars of academia unable to deal with this core reality.
Working with, dealing with, and successfully arriving at mutually beneficial and satisfactory decisions on a day-to-day basis is what the real world teaches you — sometimes harshly.
Understanding, communication and appreciating someone else’s point of view is difficult. It is seldom as the books expound, a clear rational process aided by the theories of people management.

3. Execution:
In B-school, all that you learn is from books, periodicals, case studies, which do not prepare you for the biggest differentiator in the real world: the ability to execute.
Perhaps the most understated competency needed, it hits you between the eyes the first time you try to execute a plan, a project or a campaign.
The various parameters you deal with and the fickle nature of the elements are not issues you think about in B-school.
The need to plan with buffers, with alternatives, and the need to keep an eye on the ball at all stages of execution, cannot be overemphasised.
Unfortunately, in our desire to move ourselves up the knowledge curve, there is a propensity to take this skill for granted, and most management programmes don’t expose you to this harsh reality.

4. Dealing with failure:
Learning to live with failure is another of those often not realised truths. In the real world, we are constantly dealing with the fact that not all decisions, activities, interactions, strategies, or communication translate into success.
My favourite saying is that learning comes from experience and good learning from bad experience. But no B-school teaches you to take failure in your stride.
More often than not, there is enough time to mull over a failure or even lick your wounds. Facing it with grace and bracing yourself for the next set of decisions or actions is what the real world is all about.
We will still deal with the same environment where we failed; at times, lead the same team that could not pull it off, have the same limited facts and figures and information; and more importantly, yet have the same objectives to achieve. It can be a humbling experience, which no education with books or classrooms can simulate.
Dealing with failures is paramount. Otherwise, a propensity to shy away from decision and action for fear of failure can easily become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

5. Multi-tasking:
This is probably the most common, yet the most demanding task. Unlike academics, more often than not, executives have to deal with the very real implications of their ability or inability to multi-task.
Financial, organisational and people implications are the riders we contend with. On a day-to-day basis, the ability to multi-task, yet prioritise and drop a few tasks and live with the implications is something no classroom can teach in its entirety.
To quickly estimate the impact, segregate the critical, handle them with speed and calm, constantly scan the environment for changes, and build them into your thoughts and actions as you go through the day, is an experiential learning.
Add to this the fact that often, the information available is scant or incomplete, there are always a few angles no one knew about, the unpredictability of people we are dealing with — and your hands are more than full. In hindsight, vision is often 20-20, but reality is not.
B-schools do give you an understanding of the tools, aids and theories with which you need to arm yourselves, but where they fall short is in correctly teaching the application and the virtues of experiential learning.
- Raj Raman (senior vice president, sales and marketing, Prudential ICICI AMC Ltd. Hegraduated from the Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore. )

When you can’t earn an MBA

Recently while I was going thru review of book “When you can’t earn an MBA” by RajeshShetty. as per this book he inspired by one of Seth Godin article in which he suggested that “actual experience combined wit a dedicated reading of 30 or 40 books” might be a better use of time and money than an MBA degree.It’s a good book,describing abt what you can do when you can’t earn MBA degree… he give 10 step alternate approach to MBA.@ last, he write about 10 Things that one have that the people who are pursuing MBA won’t have !!! I really like it and after reading it.. I just tried to give a second thought to it..that to invest in an MBA or not to invest in an MBA?
I posted 10 things that author talk about in book…
1 More Timeyou have two more years of time on your side. Now, if you just spend those two year with “zero” investment in yourself, you can be guaranteedthat the MBA route is far better. However, if you design your life to take advantage of those two years, then the game is different!
2 More MoneyYou save $100K in fees and earned two more year of income - may be another $200K. So you literally save $300K
3 Short-Term career advantage unless someone is doing an executive MBA program, they lose two years of their career. You don’t !! Again, how your career grows during two years is entirely up to you. In two years, you should be able to add value to your organization and grow as a person. If not, you may want to check your attitude and behavior. There may be problem that even an MBA degreecouldn’t fix.
4. More varied networking opportunities While you miss opportunities to network inside the MBA program, you get to network in your workplace, your profession, and your community. The MBA folks are often so busy that they won’t have any time to network outside their school.
5 Fewer debts to repay since you don’t have to borrow money for an MBA program, you don’t have to worry about those education loan.
6. Opportunity to get more creative Since you don’t have an MBA and you know that it’s going to be a disadvantage you need to get creative to fill the gap. You will start looking for alternate option. Here’s a quick example. We all know that communication and public speaking are two important skills that you can develop in an MBA program. You could seek out other ways to develop these skills -may be bye joining a group such as Toastmaste International
. Instead of spending $100K in tution, you might spend $100 a year in membership dues.
7. More time to develop your strength In an MBA or any educational program with a set coursework, chances are that you need to study a number of required subjects. This is true even when the subjects are :
- Not completely relevant in near future
- Not in your area of strength and/or interests.
Because you aren’t inside formal program, you will have the freedom to focus on the topics that interests you and will move you towards your goal. You can focus on continuing to read and develop your strengths.
8 Time to build your brand when you are in an MBA program, the course will be so intensive that you don’t get time to build your brand. Personal Branding is extremely important in this age of rapid commoditization. You develop a chance to build a reputation based on real-world action and achievement. Two years of focused investment in building your personal brand may provide you with a huge competitive advantage over an MBA
9 More Grounded I have heard time and again that several MBA graduates tend to be “over confident” and assume that they have that extra dash of smartness because of their MBA degree. You don’t have an MBA so you can’t have that problem. So, in essence you are more grounded on that subject that many MBA graduates.
10 TIME TO RELAX If you think getting into a good MBA program is hard work, you just have to wait until you get into one.One MBA student remarked to me once that before he joined an MBA program, he had difficulty in grasping the meaning of the term “Time Flies”. He had no problem with that term at the first quarter in his program.Once you get into an MBA program you really don’t have a choice but to keep running as fast sa you can. You are not alone. Everyone there is running.
If you are not pursuing MBA though, sometimes you can carve out some time to relax
Confused???? what to do??
well, It all depends on you.. on action you take… If you don’t take any action no knowledge in world can help you… this apply to both the cases here… to do MBA or not to do. If you don’t do MBA and don’t take any action to improve yourself it won’t work and if you do MBA and get the knowledge but still don’t take any action.. it won’t work either

Friday, June 1, 2007

B-schools don’t teach leadership skills

You can learn about management from an MBA course, but it can’t teach what kind of manager you should be.
Youneed to discover your leadership style on your own: Are you a delegatoror a hands-on manager? Should you lean more towards vision or action?Do you need to be task-driven or would it be better to buildrelationships? These are concepts you learn through 360-degree feedbackand real-life interaction, not in B-school.


A B-school can never teach you people skills. Managing teams is oftenabout building emotional bank accounts with them; that’s something youcan’t learn in an institution. Nor can an MBA course teach you toidentify and recruit senior leaders for your organisation.
Also,there isn’t enough emphasis on execution. Regular process reviews toensure strategic initiatives get converted to day-to-day operations isa critical part of running a business, but B-schools tend to overlookits importance.
Management education inIndia comes up short in dealing with global businesses. Not muchattention is paid to the intricacies of dealing with internationalcustomers and colleagues.
But perhapsthis is an area where practical experience counts more: Real life makesyou better global citizens than any course in an insulated institutioncan ever hope to. Another area where B-schools can never hope toreplicate real-life experience relates to the strategic insights anddiscoveries around new market developments.


Theability to recognise underserved or unserved markets, and act upon thatinformation, comes only when you are fully engaged in the real world.New business ideas usually spring from your operating environment, notfrom reading about business strategy.
Finally,B-schools don’t build in their students an ability to move out of theircomfort zones, whether it is behavioural (the discipline point madeabove), or about switching jobs or businesses.
Ofcourse, I don’t know how much of this is a trainable attribute, but itis a big part of big successes and needs to be recognised as such.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

keep ur PASSION burning !...

Maybe you've been wondering whether it's even right to follow your goal if it doesn't feel as exciting now. Maybe you've started making excuses to yourself in case you fail, or you can't really recall why you were so excited in the first place. Well hang on a moment! Remember you had good reasons to follow your goals at the time and you need to recall those reasons not just logically but with your heart and your feelings. Stay loyal to your goals even when it feels thankless and you will get the right reward at the right time.
"Our greatest weakness lies in giving up. The most certain way to succeed is always to try just one more time." Thomas A. Edison
People have always known that persistence and perseverance are a key ingredient in success. Hence the old saying "If at first you don't succeed, try, try again". Studies of successful entrepreneurs show that the millionaires in this world possess a tremendous level of perseverance - they stick at it not just when the going gets tough, but even when others tell them to stop.As it is said thousand of times..........
"Your work is going to fill a large part of your life, and the only way to be truly satisfied is to do what you believe is great work. And the only way to do great work is to love what you do. If you haven't found it yet, keep looking. Don't settle. As with all matters of the heart, you'll know when you find it. And, like any great relationship, it just gets better and better as the years roll on. So keep looking until you find it. Don't settle." Steve Jobs!...